Best Real Estate Agents in Big Pine Key, FL• Updated
Looking for the best real estate agent in Big Pine Key, FL? This page compares realtors in Big Pine Key within each home type and price range using actual transaction data — not reviews or paid ads. Whether you want a listing agent in Big Pine Key, FL or help buying a home in Big Pine Key, our 2026 scores use verified sales records, days on market, and sale-to-list ratios.
Market Pulse: Balanced ⚖️
The Big Pine Key, FL real estate market is currently balanced: inventory is tight, but homes are selling below asking. Homes are selling at 95% of list price on average (Sale Price to List Price Ratio). With 14 active listings and 10 closed sales in the latest month, inventory remains at 1.4 months of supply. Trends over the last half-year show median values moving up by 25%, while Average Days on Market has increased by 10%. Transaction speed in Big Pine Key is currently 9 days slower than the broader Monroe County benchmark.
Top Listing & Buyer's Agents in Big Pine Key, FL
Source: third-party closed MLS records, data as of Oct 2026. Agents are compared within each home type and price range. How we score agents →
Detached Homes
Entry Level Detached Home Market Trends Median Price Market Trend The Entry Level Detached Home tier had a median sale price of $632K over the last 6 months. Days On Market Avg. Market Trend Lower is better Detached Homes in the Entry Level range averaged 74 days on market over the last 6 months. Sale Price to List Price Ratio Market Trend Higher is better Lower is better Sellers of Entry Level Detached Homes received 96% of list price on average over the last 6 months.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Mid-Market Detached Home Market Trends Median Price Market Trend The Mid-Market Detached Home tier had a median sale price of $1M over the last 6 months. Days On Market Avg. Market Trend Lower is better Detached Homes in the Mid-Market range averaged 77 days on market over the last 6 months. Sale Price to List Price Ratio Market Trend Higher is better Lower is better Sellers of Mid-Market Detached Homes received 95% of list price on average over the last 6 months.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
High-End Detached Home Market Trends Median Price Market Trend The High-End Detached Home tier had a median sale price of $1.8M over the last 6 months. Days On Market Avg. Market Trend Lower is better Detached Homes in the High-End range averaged 73 days on market over the last 6 months. Sale Price to List Price Ratio Market Trend Higher is better Lower is better Sellers of High-End Detached Homes received 95% of list price on average over the last 6 months.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Ultra-Luxury Detached Home Market Trends Median Price Market Trend The Ultra-Luxury Detached Home tier had a median sale price of $3.5M over the last 6 months. Days On Market Avg. Market Trend Lower is better Detached Homes in the Ultra-Luxury range averaged 97 days on market over the last 6 months. Sale Price to List Price Ratio Market Trend Higher is better Lower is better Sellers of Ultra-Luxury Detached Homes received 94% of list price on average over the last 6 months.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Mobile/Manufactured Homes
Entry Level Mobile/Manufactured Home Market Trends Median Price Market Trend The Entry Level Mobile/Manufactured Home tier had a median sale price of $378K over the last 6 months. Days On Market Avg. Market Trend Lower is better Mobile/Manufactured Homes in the Entry Level range averaged 78 days on market over the last 6 months. Sale Price to List Price Ratio Market Trend Higher is better Lower is better Sellers of Entry Level Mobile/Manufactured Homes received 93% of list price on average over the last 6 months.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Big Pine Key Real Estate Market Trends October 2026
Inventory Breakdown by Segment
| Property Type | Entry Level | High-End | Mid-Market | Ultra-Luxury | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Detached Home | 4 | 1 | 9 | — | 14 |
Market Insights & FAQ
How is the real estate market in Big Pine Key, FL performing right now?
The data indicates a tight but negotiable market in Big Pine Key, FL. Inventory is at 1.4 months of supply. Inventory is tight, but homes are selling below asking on average, so buyers still have some room to negotiate despite limited choice.
What are the current pricing trends for Big Pine Key, FL real estate?
Currently, $1,157,000 represents the median entry point in Big Pine Key, FL. Over the past half-year, home values in Big Pine Key have moved upward by approximately 25% based on regional transaction data.
Are sellers in Big Pine Key, FL getting their full asking price?
Buyers have some room to negotiate in Big Pine Key, FL, with a Sale Price to List Price Ratio of 95.2%. On average, properties in Big Pine Key are transitioning from active to sold status in 86 days.
Which listing agents does Agent Algo feature in Big Pine Key, FL?
Agent Algo compares agents within the same home type and price range, so Big Pine Key, FL has no single overall winner. Featured listing agents include Patti Nickless (Entry Level Detached Homes, 5 closed listings), Sandra Tuttle (Mid-Market Detached Homes, 2 closed listings), Suzanne Moore (High-End Detached Homes, 1 closed listing). Scores are built from closed sales outcomes — not reviews or paid placements.
How does the Big Pine Key, FL market compare to Monroe County trends?
Big Pine Key, FL maintains a distinct profile within the broader Monroe County region. Median home values are currently 14% lower than the regional average, reflecting the unique demand and inventory dynamics of Big Pine Key.
Which agent is best for buying a Mid-Market Detached Home in Big Pine Key, FL?
Buyers targeting Mid-Market Detached Homes in Big Pine Key, FL may want to work with outside of mls mls. Their buyer closings in this segment show a sale-to-list ratio that's more favorable than the local average — a signal of effective negotiation that keeps final purchase prices competitive for buyers. Based on 6 closed purchases in this segment (12 in Big Pine Key, FL overall).
Which buyer's agents are active in High-End Detached Homes in Big Pine Key, FL?
Lisa Ferringo has recent High-End Detached Home purchases in Big Pine Key, FL, at a below-average sale-to-list ratio for the segment. With only a few closings in this segment, treat this as an early signal rather than a ranking. Based on 3 closed purchases in this segment.
Which buyer's agents are active in Entry Level Detached Homes in Big Pine Key, FL?
Greg Gordon has recent Entry Level Detached Home purchases in Big Pine Key, FL, closing faster than the segment average at a below-average sale-to-list ratio. With only a few closings in this segment, treat this as an early signal rather than a ranking. Based on 3 closed purchases in this segment.
Which listing agents are active in Mid-Market Detached Homes in Big Pine Key, FL?
Sandra Tuttle has recent Mid-Market Detached Home listings in Big Pine Key, FL, closing faster than the segment average at an above-average sale-to-list ratio. With only a few closings in this segment, treat this as an early signal rather than a ranking. Based on 2 closed listings in this segment (4 in Big Pine Key, FL overall).
Who is a top listing agent for Entry Level Detached Homes in Big Pine Key, FL?
If you're selling an Entry Level Detached Home in Big Pine Key, FL, the data points to Patti Nickless as a standout choice. Their Entry Level Detached Home closings in Big Pine Key, FL show an above-average sale-to-list ratio for this segment — a sign of skilled pricing and negotiation that protects seller value. Based on 5 closed listings in this segment.
Which buyer's agents are active in Entry Level Mobile/Manufactured Homes in Big Pine Key, FL?
Halley Haack has recent Entry Level Mobile/Manufactured Home purchases in Big Pine Key, FL, closing faster than the segment average at a below-average sale-to-list ratio. With only a few closings in this segment, treat this as an early signal rather than a ranking. Based on 1 closed purchase in this segment.
Which listing agents are active in Entry Level Mobile/Manufactured Homes in Big Pine Key, FL?
Darlene Alferes has recent Entry Level Mobile/Manufactured Home listings in Big Pine Key, FL, closing faster than the segment average at an above-average sale-to-list ratio. With only a few closings in this segment, treat this as an early signal rather than a ranking. Based on 2 closed listings in this segment.
Which buyer's agents are active in Ultra-Luxury Detached Homes in Big Pine Key, FL?
Annie Hagen has recent Ultra-Luxury Detached Home purchases in Big Pine Key, FL. With only a few closings in this segment, treat this as an early signal rather than a ranking. Based on 1 closed purchase in this segment.