Best Real Estate Agents in Kelleys Island, OH• Updated
Looking for the best real estate agent in Kelleys Island, OH? This page ranks the top realtors in Kelleys Island by actual transaction data — not reviews or paid ads. Whether you want to find a top listing agent in Kelleys Island, OH or buy a home in Kelleys Island, our 2026 rankings use verified sales records, days on market, and price retention to surface the highest-performing agents.
Market Pulse: Opportunity 📈
The Kelleys Island, OH real estate market is currently a Buyer's Market. Homes are retaining 95% of their value (Sale Price to List Price Ratio). With 6 active listings and 2 closed sales this month, inventory remains at 6 months of supply. Trends over the last half-year show median values moving up by 13%, while Average Days on Market has decreased by 1%. Transaction speed in Kelleys Island is currently 15 days slower than the broader Erie benchmark.
Top Listing & Buyer's Agents in Kelleys Island, OH
Detached Homes
Entry Level Detached Home Market Trends Median Price Market Trend The Entry Level Detached Home tier commands a price of $275K. Days On Market Avg. Market Trend Lower is better Detached Home homes in the Entry Level range average 53 days on market. Sale Price to List Price Ratio Market Trend Higher is better Lower is better Sellers of Entry Level Detached Home assets receive 77% of list price.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Mid-Market Detached Home Market Trends Median Price Market Trend The average price in the Mid-Market Detached Home segment has risen by 9% over the last 3 months. Days On Market Avg. Market Trend Lower is better Days on market for Mid-Market Detached Home is decreasing, with homes now staying on market for 42 days on average. Sale Price to List Price Ratio Market Trend Higher is better Lower is better Seller leverage in the Mid-Market Detached Home market is shifting towards buyers, with the Sale Price to List Price Ratio now at 94%.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
High-End Detached Home Market Trends Median Price Market Trend The High-End Detached Home tier commands a price of $749K. Days On Market Avg. Market Trend Lower is better Detached Home homes in the High-End range average 70 days on market. Sale Price to List Price Ratio Market Trend Higher is better Lower is better Sellers of High-End Detached Home assets receive 100% of list price.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Kelleys Island Real Estate Market Trends August 2026
Inventory Breakdown by Segment
| Property Type | Entry Level | High-End | Mid-Market | Ultra-Luxury | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Detached Home | — | 3 | 2 | 1 | 6 |
Market Insights & FAQ
How is the real estate market in Kelleys Island, OH performing right now?
The data indicates a stable environment in Kelleys Island, OH. Inventory is at 6 months, meaning a balanced environment with steady turnover. Inventory levels provide a healthy range of options for prospective buyers.
What are the current pricing trends for Kelleys Island, OH real estate?
Currently, $524,000 represents the median entry point in Kelleys Island, OH. Over the past half-year, home values in Kelleys Island have moved upward by approximately 13% based on regional transaction data.
Are sellers in Kelleys Island, OH getting their full asking price?
Buyers have room for negotiation in Kelleys Island, OH, with a Sale Price to List Price Ratio of 94.8%. On average, properties in Kelleys Island are transitioning from active to sold status in 60 days.
Who is the best agent to sell my home in Kelleys Island?
Based on closed transaction data, Jason Smith ranks at the top of our Kelleys Island leaderboard — with 4 completed transactions on record earning an algorithm performance score of 42. Agent Algo's rankings are built entirely from real deal outcomes — not reviews or paid placements — so this reflects actual results in the local market.
How does the Kelleys Island, OH market compare to Erie trends?
Kelleys Island, OH maintains a distinct profile within the broader Erie region. Median home values are currently 74% higher than the regional average, reflecting the unique demand and inventory dynamics of Kelleys Island.
Which agent is best for buying a Entry Level Detached Home in Kelleys Island, OH?
Buyers targeting Entry Level Detached Home homes in Kelleys Island, OH may want to work with Jason Smith. Their buyer transactions in the Entry Level Detached Home category in Kelleys Island, OH reflect genuine niche experience — a meaningful advantage over agents working this segment only occasionally.
Which agent is best for buying a Mid-Market Detached Home in Kelleys Island, OH?
Our data flags Lisa Yako as a top buyer's advocate for Mid-Market Detached Home properties in Kelleys Island, OH. The data shows a consistent pattern across their deals here: shorter time to close than the segment average, and acquisition terms that tend to land below-average relative to list price. Two things buyers care about most.
Who is a top listing agent for Mid-Market Detached Home homes in Kelleys Island, OH?
Among agents with recent closings in the Mid-Market Detached Home space, Jason Smith has the strongest performance metrics in Kelleys Island, OH. Speed and price retention together are the hardest combination to find in a single agent. Their track record in the Mid-Market Detached Home category in Kelleys Island, OH reflects both.
Which agent is best for buying a Ultra-Luxury Detached Home in Kelleys Island, OH?
Among agents actively helping buyers in the Ultra-Luxury Detached Home space, David Tully stands out in Kelleys Island, OH. Their buyer transactions in the Ultra-Luxury Detached Home category in Kelleys Island, OH reflect genuine niche experience — a meaningful advantage over agents working this segment only occasionally.
Who is a top listing agent for High-End Detached Home homes in Kelleys Island, OH?
When looking specifically at High-End Detached Home transactions, David Tully consistently surfaces as a top performer in Kelleys Island, OH. Our algorithm ranks them based on closed transaction outcomes in the High-End Detached Home segment, not self-reported volume or marketing activity. The ranking reflects actual local performance.
Which agent is best for buying a High-End Detached Home in Kelleys Island, OH?
For those looking to purchase a High-End Detached Home in Kelleys Island, OH, William Gallagher has the deal history to support the choice. Buying in the High-End Detached Home space has its own dynamics. William Gallagher's history of closed deals in this exact category in Kelleys Island, OH shows they understand those dynamics well.
Who is a top listing agent for Ultra-Luxury Detached Home homes in Kelleys Island, OH?
In the Ultra-Luxury Detached Home category, few agents in Kelleys Island, OH can match the track record of David Tully. They've built a consistent track record in the Ultra-Luxury Detached Home category specifically — not just broad volume, but demonstrated results in this exact niche in Kelleys Island, OH.
Who is a top listing agent for Entry Level Detached Home homes in Kelleys Island, OH?
Jason Smith specializes in Entry Level Detached Home properties and has built a measurable edge in Kelleys Island's market. Our algorithm ranks them based on closed transaction outcomes in the Entry Level Detached Home segment, not self-reported volume or marketing activity. The ranking reflects actual local performance.