Best Real Estate Agents in New Middletown, OH• Updated Oct 2026

The data indicates a high-intensity environment in New Middletown, OH. Inventory is at 1.4 months, meaning a fast-paced market where inventory is limited. Inventory is critically low, meaning well-priced homes move rapidly often with multiple offers.

Currently, $288,000 represents the median entry point in New Middletown, OH. Over the past half-year, home values in New Middletown have moved upward by approximately 7% based on regional transaction data.

Buyers have room for negotiation in New Middletown, OH, with a Sale Price to List Price Ratio of 96.8%. On average, properties in New Middletown are transitioning from active to sold status in 45 days.

Based on closed transaction data, Holly Ritchie ranks at the top of our New Middletown leaderboard earning an algorithm performance score of -42. Agent Algo's rankings are built entirely from real deal outcomes — not reviews or paid placements — so this reflects actual results in the local market.

New Middletown, OH maintains a distinct profile within the broader Mahoning region. Median home values are currently 2% higher than the regional average, reflecting the unique demand and inventory dynamics of New Middletown.

Buyers targeting Mid-Market Detached Home homes in New Middletown, OH may want to work with Lorene Moderalli. Their buyer transactions in this segment close faster than the local norm and at sale-to-list ratios that are more favorable than typical — meaning they move quickly and negotiate effectively for the buyers they represent.

Our data flags Robert Dull as a top buyer's advocate for Mid-Market Condo/Co-op properties in New Middletown, OH. The data shows a consistent pattern across their deals here: shorter time to close than the segment average, and acquisition terms that tend to land below-average relative to list price. Two things buyers care about most.

Among agents with recent closings in the Mid-Market Detached Home space, Holly Ritchie has the strongest performance metrics in New Middletown, OH. Speed and price retention together are the hardest combination to find in a single agent. Their track record in the Mid-Market Detached Home category in New Middletown, OH reflects both.

Among agents actively helping buyers in the Entry Level Detached Home space, Robert Dull stands out in New Middletown, OH. Their buyer closings in this segment show a sale-to-list ratio that's more favorable than the local average — a signal of effective negotiation that keeps final purchase prices competitive for buyers.

When looking specifically at Entry Level Detached Home transactions, Jeri Cameron consistently surfaces as a top performer in New Middletown, OH. The data points to a dual edge here: shorter time on market than is typical for this segment, and sale prices that hold closer to — or above — the asking price compared to local norms.

For those looking to purchase a High-End Detached Home in New Middletown, OH, Susan Younger has the deal history to support the choice. Buying effectively in this segment means knowing when and how hard to push. Their track record here shows they regularly outperform the local sale-to-list benchmark — in the buyer's favor.

Navigating New Middletown's Mid-Market Multi-Family (2-4 Unit) market as a buyer? Kay Zabivnik is among the most effective agents in this niche. Their buyer transactions in the Mid-Market Multi-Family (2-4 Unit) category in New Middletown, OH reflect genuine niche experience — a meaningful advantage over agents working this segment only occasionally.

Jill Egolf specializes in Mid-Market Multi-Family (2-4 Unit) properties and has built a measurable edge in New Middletown's market. Our algorithm ranks them based on closed transaction outcomes in the Mid-Market Multi-Family (2-4 Unit) segment, not self-reported volume or marketing activity. The ranking reflects actual local performance.