Best Real Estate Agents in Utica, OH• Updated Aug 2026

The data indicates a active environment in Utica, OH. Inventory is at 3.8 months, meaning a balanced environment with steady turnover. Inventory is balanced but lean, requiring buyers to be decisive.

Currently, $289,000 represents the median entry point in Utica, OH. Over the past half-year, home values in Utica have moved upward by approximately 1% based on regional transaction data.

Buyers have room for negotiation in Utica, OH, with a Sale Price to List Price Ratio of 98%. On average, properties in Utica are transitioning from active to sold status in 58 days.

Based on closed transaction data, Sibley Poland ranks at the top of our Utica leaderboard — with 2 completed transactions on record earning an algorithm performance score of 25. Agent Algo's rankings are built entirely from real deal outcomes — not reviews or paid placements — so this reflects actual results in the local market.

Utica, OH maintains a distinct profile within the broader Licking region. Median home values are currently 22% lower than the regional average, reflecting the unique demand and inventory dynamics of Utica.

If you're selling a Mid-Market Detached Home in Utica, OH, the data points to Sibley Poland as a standout choice. Their listings in this segment have consistently closed faster than the local average while achieving above-average sale-to-list ratios — a rare combination that directly benefits sellers on both time and final price.

Our data flags Megan Winstead as a top buyer's advocate for Mid-Market Detached Home properties in Utica, OH. Our algorithm surfaces Megan Winstead based on actual closed buyer deals in the Mid-Market Detached Home market. That's the kind of specific, verifiable track record buyers should look for in an agent.

Among agents with recent closings in the Entry Level Detached Home space, Amanda Allgood has the strongest performance metrics in Utica, OH. For sellers who want to move efficiently without overpricing, their track record in the Entry Level Detached Home niche shows they deliver timely closes — consistently faster than the segment norm.

Among agents actively helping buyers in the Entry Level Detached Home space, Kathy Ford stands out in Utica, OH. Their buyer transactions in this segment close faster than the local norm and at sale-to-list ratios that are more favorable than typical — meaning they move quickly and negotiate effectively for the buyers they represent.

Sandy Raines has a strong showing as a buyer's agent in Utica's High-End Detached Home market. The data shows a consistent pattern across their deals here: shorter time to close than the segment average, and acquisition terms that tend to land below-average relative to list price. Two things buyers care about most.

For those looking to purchase a Ultra-Luxury Detached Home in Utica, OH, Ben Calhoon has the deal history to support the choice. For buyers competing in the Ultra-Luxury Detached Home market in Utica, OH, their track record indicates speed and negotiating strength that outperforms the segment baseline on both counts.

In the High-End Detached Home category, few agents in Utica, OH can match the track record of K Shannon Cook. Their listings in this segment have consistently closed faster than the local average while achieving above-average sale-to-list ratios — a rare combination that directly benefits sellers on both time and final price.

Shelley Cottrell specializes in Ultra-Luxury Detached Home properties and has built a measurable edge in Utica's market. Shelley Cottrell has consistently held closer to asking price than the typical Ultra-Luxury Detached Home agent in Utica, OH. For sellers prioritizing their final number, that's the metric that matters most.